I played some test dynasty games with San Jose State and Colorado this weekend, and into my Junior year as a QB for Cal in Road to Glory. In high school games, I was a man among boys, routinely throwing for 300 or 400 yards, but also threw a couple of picks a game it seemed on greedy throws. Trying to laser one down a seam when the safety was still in his backpedal and looking right at me.
But I LOVE having a "default" difficulty this year. Every previous iteration of the RTG mode, I'd sign onto Cal and most likely start in week 1 due to how I played in high school. In this season, since they have it set to All-American if you choose, and make it much harder to get coaches trust to move up the depth chart, I sat my entire first year on the bench. In practice, I'd get maybe 5 points for a 10 or 15 yard pass completion...but I'd get -100 points for a single pick. -50 for a fumble, and -20 for a sack. When you can't audible and can't hot route in practice, if you throw 1 or 2 picks in 25 reps, you actually go backwards in your progress on All-American. I can't even imagine what it is on Heisman.
By the end of my freshman year my ratings were really climbing, because you get a lot of XP for completions and big plays, but I made enough mistakes to still be sitting at ZERO coaches trust as the 3rd string scout team QB. My sophomore year I started making progress, and at one point had enough to actually move up to challenge #2--and then threw 2 interceptions and was back to zero.
My sophomore year came to a close and I finally went mistake-free enough to challenge the #2 QB, and destroyed him in a head to head competition (it's funny that the position battles are XP-based, whereas moving up the depth chart is all Coaches Trust-based). So I closed out my sophomore year as #2 on the depth chart behind a Senior starter. He graduated, and when my Junior year started--I was still #2. The guy I beat last year leap-frogged me into the starter's role, which made no sense. You'd think I'd have just ascended to the starting role if the starter graduated and I was #2, but no..they want you to jump through those hoops to do so.
So I managed to go mistake free in the opening week (Cal's bye week) of 2014, then won the position battle in week 2 to start opening day of my Junior year. I proceeded to throw 3 touchdowns and about 250 yards because I was a high-90's rated player by that point, throwing a TD pass with :25 left to beat Northwestern 21-14 on opening day.
Then I threw 6 picks in the next 3 games, and my Coaches Trust plummeted back to -200. By week 5 I was back on the bench, and the cycle continued. It's the first time I ever lost my starting job in one of these games, and it was actually pretty frustratingly cool. I don't know how "fun" it is, but it sure does feel real to struggle through most of your career and have your ass firmly planted on the bench.
