Both my rentals are up Tuesday but i've played the game on both systems this weekend.
First of all, I like the game, but a lot of stuff frustrates me. One being the god damn passing game. You ncaa guru's out there, HOW THE f*** do you put together 2 scoring drives in this game without running the ball all the time? Also, if you like to play your games around 30 min., forget about it. Unless you got all the time in the world or you're currently a prisoner at Gitmo, this damn f***in game will take at least an hour to play on 5 min qtrs. I set my qtrs to 3min and I can get a game done around 35-40 min.
Now for my system evaluations. Ok, the xbox version is graphically awesome . This is the first year I played the game for Xbox and it's so much more superior than the ps2 version. The ps2 versions colors are a little bit more deeper but that's about it. The ps2 version is a jaggy mess during day games and looks better in night games. Xbox is clear and very pretty to look at. The players in the xbox version look like football players while the ps2 players still look like madden2001. The player detailed uniforms on the xbox verison are awesome to look at during replays. Of course you have the xbox advantage with loading times and unlimited saves.
For Gameplay, this is a tough one. The ps2 version plays more looser while the Xbox version plays tighter. I dont know any other way to explain this. Maybe it's the controllers since the ps2 buttons and analogs are softer than the xbox buttons and analog. The xbox version plays at a little faster pace than the ps2 version. I find this both to be good and bad depending how you like to play. On offense you can really feel the difference since with the ps2 controller it seems like you can get the ball faster to the WR but at a slower pace, it sounds confusing but does that sort of make sense? On the Xbox version you click on the button and the ball gets there a little slower but overall at a faster pace. It's mofo hard to explain this into words i know.
Also, It seems like I get more dropped passes on the Xbox version than the ps2 version. IN the ps2 version it's really not even a thought about drops, but on the xbox version I get them from time to time. Maybe it's me not being use to the harder buttons on the xbox controller since it's my first time with this game on the box. The juke stick is much better with the Xbox version too. The ps2 stick is a little looser so you may have your move read incorrectly at times.
defense: the defense is much more responsive on the xbox version than the ps2 version, especially the DB's. The DB's seem to get to the ball faster in the xbox version. So it seems that the Xbox version plays a better defensive game, even though I still suck at defense in both verisons.
Ok, so everything tells you the Xbox version is better right? Well for me, I dont know what the hell it is, I dont know why, but I have more fun playing the ps2 version. Maybe it's the controller, maybe it's the slower pace, maybe it's because this game I've always played with the ps1/ps2, I dont know, I just have more fun playing the ps2 version. Even when I get my ass handed to me in games by halftime, I can take it on the ps2 version while it feels like some cyborg frustration hellhole on the xbox version. That's how I found the 'SIM GAME TO END' option on the Xbox version, if you didnt know it existed , here is how you get to it : Pause game - Click Quit - Click Yes.
The ps2 version feels like a 'videogame' to me which equates to a more fun not too serious football feeling. On the Xbox, I feel like I am actually on the field throwing picks left and right and begging for the coach to take me out since I can't take it anymore (quitter=me, ya i know). Maybe EA's conditioned me to have fun on a system with jaggies all over the place and slow load times, but I just have more fun playing the ps2 version.
I will buy this game this week but I dont know what version I should get even though I've played both extensively. I like the fun factor I get out of the ps2 version so I am leaning toward that. But I also like the graphics, better defensive controls, fast load times , and unlimited saves of the xbox version too.