
Best wishes,
Doug
Moderators: Bill_Abner, ScoopBrady
England is probably unique in having 92 professional clubs (may be more, but I don't know how many Blue Square League teams are full time), but most of them sort of bumble along in reasonable health. They aren't subsidized by anything other than smallish TV contracts either. The reason people go to watch them is that they are their local clubs and a real part of the community, rather than corporate franchises, which is why, for the most part, Americans don't understand them - though people from other nations with a soccer culture do. These clubs started as works teams, pub teams, church teams - not as franchises to be bought, traded and moved on a whim.wco81 wrote:How many teams get promoted and climb the ladder and stay at the top divisions?
Maybe not become perennial CL teams but threaten to or play often in the UEFA Cup?
As for the lower leagues, it sounds like many clubs are struggling, even before the global economic slowdown.
Have any of them folded or have the lower leagues consolidated?
There may be a historical tradition at many of these smaller clubs but are they being propped up (subsidized) just to maintain this promotion/relegation structure?
Why aren't people in smaller towns just watching the top divisions and CL games on TV instead of supporting small-time teams?
In the US, the promotion and relegation system wouldn't work. MLB has minor leagues only because the big league teams foot much of the bills -- or at least cover the payroll for the prospects. But those minor league teams wouldn't be able to come up and compete perennially against the big leagues.
There were about 3 Newcastle players who looked gutted at the end - the rest of them, Owen included, just looked like they were thinking about tomorrow's phone calls...travel agent first, their own agent second.Macca00 wrote:Thoughts from today;
- So glad c*** won and a fantastic match (EDIT: LOL, forgot that the forum won't let me write S C U N THORPE lol!)
- Newcastle are utter wank - those players should be forced to go down and play in the Championship, they were absolutely pathetic - no intensity or desire whatsoever, I'm just disgusted by their performance and I'm not even a Newcastle supporter
Good post from a Bengals fan. Haha I had to throw that in there because had the NFL had relegation, the Bengals would be in the Blue Square North.davet010 wrote:England is probably unique in having 92 professional clubs (may be more, but I don't know how many Blue Square League teams are full time), but most of them sort of bumble along in reasonable health. They aren't subsidized by anything other than smallish TV contracts either. The reason people go to watch them is that they are their local clubs and a real part of the community, rather than corporate franchises, which is why, for the most part, Americans don't understand them - though people from other nations with a soccer culture do. These clubs started as works teams, pub teams, church teams - not as franchises to be bought, traded and moved on a whim.wco81 wrote:How many teams get promoted and climb the ladder and stay at the top divisions?
Maybe not become perennial CL teams but threaten to or play often in the UEFA Cup?
As for the lower leagues, it sounds like many clubs are struggling, even before the global economic slowdown.
Have any of them folded or have the lower leagues consolidated?
There may be a historical tradition at many of these smaller clubs but are they being propped up (subsidized) just to maintain this promotion/relegation structure?
Why aren't people in smaller towns just watching the top divisions and CL games on TV instead of supporting small-time teams?
In the US, the promotion and relegation system wouldn't work. MLB has minor leagues only because the big league teams foot much of the bills -- or at least cover the payroll for the prospects. But those minor league teams wouldn't be able to come up and compete perennially against the big leagues.
Most of these teams don't give a s*** about the CL (and neither do I, to be honest - it's a UEFA cash cow which distorts leagues particularly in smaller countries.) The Europa League (or UEFA Cup as was) is a complete waste of time - 21 games to turn a profit of £5m....BFW to that, in a big way.
There are teams in the lower leagues with fantastic histories....Preston NE, Blackpool, Leeds....Nottm Forest, who've won as many European Cups as Barcelona, Norwich who've just been relegated to the third tier, but 15 years ago beat Bayern Munich in Germany. Some of these are still pulling in crowds of 25-30,000 in the third tier.
As for consolidation, the only recent movement has been the introduction of automatic promotion and relegation between Div 2 and the Conference, which is to all intents and purposes Div 3.
And here's a final stat for you - the Premiership has been going for only 16 years, and yet of the 92 teams in the League, 42 have played at least one season at the top level, and only 7 have been ever present. So clubs can come up, stay up and challenge for UEFA cup spots - I seem to remember that at some time during the life of the Prem, Fulham were in the fourth tier and Man City have been in the third tier.
Promotion and relegation helps prevent mediocrity being an aim in itself...it might be a result of how good you are, but any team that tries to settle for it will find themselves sweating up a storm on the last day of the season. Give me that instead of the Los Angeles Clippers any day of the week, because that is what English soccer fans would never pay to see, that 'F**k it, season's only just started but we've got no chance so who cares' attitude.
I have no idea what you point is, but I believe that you stadium only has to meet Football League qualifications to go from Blue Square Premier into League 2. So in theory, a team with 3k stadium could play in the EPL. However, the police would probably make them move the matches to a bigger stadium plus the whole revenue part of it.wco81 wrote:But all those clubs are shooting for promotion, yeah?
That means that they have to build stadia which are big enough for potential EPL games. Seems any club with aspirations for excellence are quickly going to drop pretensions of a little community enterprise.
They must have sponsorships (signage with corporate logos) and so on.
Plus, the CL is what every top player seems to aspire to. They want to compete at the highest level.
It's not like Olympic basketball or baseball. Players take satisfaction in representing their countries but the highest achievement in most professional team sports occur outside of the Olympics.
The CL isn't just some spectacle, it is a pooling of the best teams in the best leagues. It's not exactly a series of exhibitions.
You cannot discount the six FA Cups and four First Division Championships, no matter when they occurred. I don't know how you define history, but Newcastle were very good from 1905-1911, appearing in the FA Cup finals 5 of those years. After WWII they won the FA Cup 3 times in a space of 5 years in the 1950s. And you cannot forget the 1995-96 season in which NUFC almost won the Premier League, eventually losing out to ManU by 4 points. Sure, they are not at the same level of titles and cups as the elite clubs, but NUFC does have a very long and storied history, not to mention a ridiculously rabid fan base all things considered. St. James was drawing over 60,000 supporters a match as far back as the 1930s, and damn near 70,000 some games. Obviously the stadium seats less now (52,000 or so), but the point is the supporters have been pouring in by the droves for over 100 years to see this club play, cups or no cups. There is a very long and colorful history throughout that span.davet010 wrote:I love this perception about Newcastle having 'history'....between the wars, maybe. One cup (UEFA) in nearly 60 years and no domestic trophy since 1952 does not constitute history
Or the 12 point lead they squandered, or KK's televised meltdown. They tend not to talk about 95-96 too much up here, or anything much more recent than Jackie Milburn.toonarmy wrote:And you cannot forget the 1995-96 season in which NUFC almost won the Premier League, eventually losing out to ManU by 4 points.
"I would just LUV to beat them ... "toonarmy wrote:And you cannot forget the 1995-96 season in which NUFC almost won the Premier League, eventually losing out to ManU by 4 points.
Where's the Canaries? Oh, that's right, both my teams got relegated this year. It's been hard enough following Norwich in the Championship. I might as well give up trying to follow them in League One from here in the States. Newcastle has a big enough following that surely a good number of its games will be televised so that I can see them via the Internet. If not, next season will end up just being a long wait for the World Cup.fsquid wrote:Championship next year
Barnsley
Blackpool
Bristol City
Cardiff City
Coventry
Crystal Palace
Derby
Doncaster
Ipswich
Leicester
Middlesbrough
Newcastle United
Nottingham Forest
Peterborough
Plymouth
Preston
QPR
Reading
c***
Sheffield United
Sheffield Wednesday
Swansea
Watford
West Brom
That isn't a bad lineup. Will be a very tough league.