Sully wrote:10spro wrote:
But what B. Clarke did last year with R. Kesler was just stupid.
Well, the idea is to offer more for the player, with hopes that their current club won't match. I don't see how Clarke's offer to Kesler last year was worse than Lowe's. Vanek would've probably made about 3-3.5 million this year before the offer, now it's double that.
Clarke's offer to Kesler was much worse because it's questionable if Clarke even wanted the player. Going after an RFA for a one-year contract? Come on.
It's obvious that Clarke just wanted to f*ck with Dave Nonis and Vancouver. Not sure of the grudge there, but Ray Charles could have seen that Clarke wanted to play with the system more than he wanted to land Kesler.
Lowe, on the other hand, offered a long-term, $40 million-plus deal to Vanek. That kind of financial and calendar commitment shows his desire to get the player was stronger than his desire to f*ck with Darcy Regier and the Sabres.
That said, the Canucks were only put out a couple of million bucks because of Clarke's folly, while Buffalo probably had to pay Vanek about $20 million more than if Lowe didn't make the offer. So I can see why Regier is pissed, although I still insist Lowe's offer was a hell of a lot more sincere than Clarke's.
Sully wrote:When all is said and done, I think Edmonton will be quite happy that Buffalo matched the offer. I'm not convinced Vanek is amongst the game's elite, despite being paid as if he were.
Agreed. Did Vanek score 43 last season because he was the "forgotten star" in Buffalo as coaches tried to match lines to stop Briere and Drury's lines? Or could Vanek score 43 as the primary offensive threat for a team?
I tend to lean toward the former, but we'll find out this season as Vanek will be target No. 1 for any coach making line combinations against Buffalo.
Take care,
PK
"You know why I love boxers? I love them because they face fear. And they face it alone." - Nick Charles
"First on the throttle, last on the brakes." - @MotoGP Twitter signature
XBL Gamertag: pk4425