Dave wrote:
A few things:
1. I think you're expecting and wanting too much, way more than 99% of the market wants. If I want a shitty golf swing, I'll hit the range. The 1:1 motion should correlate to how far back the on-screen golfer brings his/her club back and the power associated with that much of a backswing. I don't want a Charles Barkley-looking swing in a game because I accidentally took the Wiimote out too far after my backswing.
2. One thing that I think gets overlooked when people criticize the controls in a Wii game is how difficult it must be to develop a precise control system that is also forgiving enough to account for the range of motions people use. Potter for the Wii was a good example of a game that expected way too specific motions, but that leads to...
3. Wii Motion Control Plus, or whatever the hell it is called, is being introduced for a reason--the tech in the Wiimote/system isn't that accurate.
It's true that video games represent star athletes so people are used to video games representing things you can't do in real life.
But the Wii was marketed as a revolution. You saw those videos of grandparents playing with their grandkids, making gentle motions in harmony with the onscreen characters they're suppose to be controlling.
Fact that it's just detecting motion (instead of translating your motion to the screen) in place of button presses may be a nuance which the casual players who've bought the Wii in such mass numbers probably miss.
Obviously they're still having a lot of fun with it.
Maybe Tiger's brand doesn't allow duffers to make virtual Tiger look bad in his game. Maybe they have to do it with cartoony characters or the Bill Murray character in Caddyshack so that you can make him take silly swings.
As for the Motionplus, I don't think that will do it. It's not just that the input device isn't capable enough. It's also that the video system have to be able to render the input in real time, rather than use captured animations which are already in the game.
You may be right that the market doesn't want to see themselves in the game, they want to see themselves as Tiger.[/b]