ddtrane wrote:
Have you tried NHL07 on the PS2? It also has the skill stick, but it is a much better experience.
Perhaps for you, but for me using the R-stick for stick handling and shooting is as fresh and new and fun an experience as I've had with a sports game in a long, long time. I don't have a Wii yet, though, so that my trump it, but shooting and deking is so damn fun in this game, I have a smile on my face on many occasions, and more importantly, I feel fully in control of the shooting. Where it goes, how much zip is on it and so on is all up to me, not to mention the fakes. This new control element combined with the absence of a turbo is enough by far for me to overlook the many boogers this game has, but of course I don't play v. CPU too much. I did really like using the R-stick for passing back with Rivals (not to mention multi-Xbox multiplayer. . . .

), but shooting in this game and deking gives me as much a feeling of control over those elements as I have in WE, which is to say more than anything else by a long shot.
EDIT: Wow, I can't read, huh? Somehow I thought trane was talking about 2K. . . ugh. Sorry trane!