toonarmy wrote:What's everyone's take on the Castrol world driver rankings? They rank over 2000 drivers, and even have countries ranked. For 2009 there were 4 F1 drivers, 3 IRL drivers, 2 WRC drivers, and one NASCAR driver (Jimmie Johnson #5) in the top ten. Clearly the weighting within the points system is questionable, but an interesting concept nonetheless.
I'm a bit confused by it, in truth. I understand the purpose of the football ranking they've got going, because they play the same game in the Premier League as they do in Serie A, La Liga or wherever, but motorsport's not exactly like that. There are good touring car drivers, good sportscar drivers, good single-seater drivers. That's where the weightings come in, sure, but as you say, those weightings are questionable.
I note that in the guide to how the ratings are calculated on the Castrol Rankings website, equal 3rd place is 'Le Mans 24 Hours'. Just that race? LMS? ALMS? Why is WTCC, home of Gabriele Tarquini, Alain Menu, Yvan Muller and Andy Priaulx to name only four, ranked lower than the A1GP series that gave us the magnificent Team Lebanon? If car performance isn't factored in, then a guy finishing 10th in a car that doesn't deserve it won't feature, even if he's doing more with what he has than anyone else in the field.
There's too much about it that either needs further explanation or just doesn't seem correct for me to view it that seriously. It's something to view out of curiosity, but I feel that the only true and fair comparison remains the one made between drivers in the same series.