Spooky wrote:greggsand wrote:Spooky wrote:
As far as the stereo remasters go...I am having a hard time hearing a significant difference compared to the original CD releases. My somewhat extensive comparisons have led me to believe that the remasters basically have a bit fuller sound, more mid-range and feel overall warmer sounding. But on some tracks I can barely notice any difference. At one point I was wondering if my 'aquired' copy was legit and was thinking that perhaps I was only hearing differnces in the way it was digiatlly converted as compared to my itunes ripped copies.
Anyone else have experiecne with direct comparisons between the new stereo remasters and the original CD releases? Should I be hearing a much more noticable difference?
I did a direct comparison between the remasters and my original CD's. Hard Days Night, Rubber Soul, and Revolver are pretty noticeable IMO. Abbey Road, not so much. Sometimes your ears (and sound system) can be deceiving. Turn on the iTunes Waveform (or something similar) and you'll visually see the difference in the levels.
Oh, yeah, there is a volume difference, but I always find that to be kind of cheating. I always 'normalize' the volume on ALL my music anyway so after doing that the sonic differences became even less noticable. It's funny...I hear a fair difference in Magical Mystery Tour and some stuff on Revolver, but like you said, not much difference at all on the later stuff especially Abbey Road. Funny thing is that in a lot of the more negative, critical reviews I've read people seem to think that Abbey Road shows a bigger improvement than the others. Very strange.
I didn't catch the differences in Abbey Road until I put on headphones (my headphone setup is way better than my stereo system). The space and subtleties (lots of little background bits, able to discern each voice in the harmonies) were very apparent when I A/B'd with the 1987 cd. "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" is massive sounding now. The White Album is another one that shines in the remastering; again, "Helter Skelter" is a monster, and "Ob-La-Di" doesn't completely suck. The White Album is probably the most listened to album in my life (my mom says I used to listen to it all day every day as a toddler, and I don't think a month passes without a listen even now), and the remasters made me feel like I was actually hearing it for the first time.
Overall, the remastering (to my ears) finally restores the low end to their proper place. The Beatles, despite all the frills and finery of the later albums, were propulsive, with a great rhythm section. The Mono mixes of the singles really shows this to great effect - as Spooky said, just crank "Day Tripper" and feel it. "Rain" is another good one as Ringo just smokes. Or check out Paul's bass on "Taxman" - I played bass for a while and I can't figure out exactly what he's doing when George is singing about "taxing the street." Some wild hammer-on and glissando thing, all supple power.
I'm kind of peeved that they didn't put out a "Definitive Beatles" set, with mono mixes through The White Album, and stereo for Submarine through Let It Be, with the proper single mixes as well. Or at least include both mono & stereo together, because I just don't have $450-500 to blow on both.